Discussion Board for Science and Religion - RELG 340 - Dr. Rollinson's courses and resources

The Discussion Board is intended to help you develop skills in communication, and encourage participation by all students in the course. You will all have to take an active part in learning and discussions with your classmates.

If you need help with the technical aspects of a Discussion Board (how to post a thread, how to reply to a thread, etc.) see the Help files on BlackBoard. Other technical help may be obtained by calling the Computer Help Desk at 575-562-4357 or from the BlackBoard coordinator, Ellen Gardiner 575-562-2390, Ellen.Gardiner@enmu.edu

Discussing Religion is fraught with more than the usual dangers of misunderstanding and anger. Our religious beliefs (or lack of them) are a basic part of our personality, and we tend to feel threatened when encountering other world-views. Please be very careful in your remarks and replies to state your position carefully, with due consideration for the beliefs and feeling of your classmates. Please do not react hastily to any remark which angers you or which you take personally, but try to understand the underlying reasons for the remark, and then reply courteously if appropriate.
Flaming or any attempt to start a Flame War will result in removal from the Discussion Board (and a grade of "F") and may result in closure of the Discussion Board.

Think before you post or send
Read through your message carefully and thoughtfully before you post or send.
If in doubt - don't send it

Your threads should be 300-500 words long. You may write more if you wish.
What you write should be relevant to the topic or question asked.
Be sure to address all parts of a question.
Read the question carefully, and think about it, before you start to write your thread.
Plan to use an introductory paragraph, then develop your thread through at least one more paragraph, and end with a concluding paragraph.
Use correct grammar, spelling, and style. Aim for a polite slightly formal style, rather than being colloquial or using slang or abbreviations.
Use complete sentences and a connected sequence of ideas.
Be sure to cite any sources you use outside the textbook and the course notes.
Try not to copy large chunks of the textbook or notes, and do not copy and paste from the InterNet - always try to express yourself in your own words.
Prepare your thread in a Word-processor, read it carefully, edit it, and save it to disc before posting it.
Threads should be posted by 9 am Wednesday of the relevant week.

Read all your classmates' threads, and reply to at least 2 of them
If possible, choose threads which deal with different topics.
Make it clear to whom you are replying, by putting a title such as "Reply to Joe Student" in the Subject line of the reply.
Each reply should be 100-200 words long and contain at least two positive comments about the thread and one suggestion, addition, or question to think about.
Do you have any particular insights and/or experiences which might be helpful to the poster or to your classmates as a whole?
Replies should be posted by 9 am Friday of the relevant week.

NOTE - "I like what you said." or "I agree" and similar remarks are not adequate replies - you must say why you agree or disagree, and you must do so constructively.

Discussion Board Introductions
Introduce yourself to your classmates, by posting an introductory message to the Discussion Board on BlackBoard.
Things to include might be the State and/or country in which you live, your Major, your interests and hobbies, and what you want to get out of this course.
Get to know your classmates by reading their messages.
You do not need to reply to any messages, but you may do so if you wish.
Students who enter the course during the Drop-Add period should introduce themselves and endeavor to catch up with the class as soon as possible. The Discussion Board is set up to allow late submissions.

Discussion Board 1, Module 1
Thread - Whom would you most like to have been :
Nicolaus Copernicus, Galileo Galilei, Thomas Paine, Francis Bacon, Gottfried Wilhelm Leibnitz, René Descartes, Erwin Schrödinger?
Choose whom you would most like to have been, write an account of his life, and say why you chose him rather than any of the others.
Replies to 2 of your classmates' threads - If possible, choose Threads which deal with different people.
What are your thoughts about the people chosen, and their influence on the dialog between Science and Religion?

Discussion Board 2, Module 2
Thread - Whom would you most like to have been :
Charles Darwin, William Paley, Michael Behe, William Jennings Bryan, Clarence Darrow ?
Choose whom you would most like to have been, write an account of his life, and say why you chose him rather than any of the others.
Replies to 2 of your classmates' threads - If possible, choose Threads which deal with different people.
What are your thoughts about the people chosen, and their influence on the dialog between Science and Religion?

Discussion Board 3, Module 3
Thread - Whom would you most like to have as a mentor :
William D. Phillips, W. Mark Richardson, Ian Barbor, C. P. Snow, Albert Einstein, Neils Bohr, Alec Turing, Pauline Rudd, Paula Tallal ?
Choose the person with whom you would most like to work, write an account of his/her life, and say why you chose him/her rather than any of the others.
Replies to 2 of your classmates' threads - If possible, choose Threads which deal with different people.
What are your thoughts about the people chosen, and their influence on the dialog between Science and Religion?

Discussion Board 4, Module 4
Thread - Whom would you most like to have been :
Thomas Young, James Clerk Maxwell, Max Planck, Paul Dirac?
Choose whom you would most like to have been, write an account of his life, and say why you chose him rather than any of the others.
Replies to 2 of your classmates' threads - If possible, choose Threads which deal with different people.
What are your thoughts about the people chosen, and their influence on the dialog between Science and Religion?

Discussion Board 5, Module 5
Thread - Whom would you most like to have been :
Isaac Newton, Werner Heisenberg, Boris Podolski, Nathan Rosen?
Choose whom you would most like to have been, write an account of his life, and say why you chose him rather than any of the others.
Replies to 2 of your classmates' threads - If possible, choose Threads which deal with different topics. What are your thoughts about the people chosen, and their influence on the dialog between Science and Religion?

Discussion Board 6, Module 6
Thread - What insights has Dr. Polkinghorne's book given you into the dialog between Science and Religion? Discuss at least one new idea which came to you as you read this book
Replies to 2 of your classmates' threads - What are your thoughts about the insights and ideas of your classmates?

Discussion Board 7, Module 7
Thread - Whom would you most like to have as a mentor :
Khalil Chamcham, Faraneh Vargha-Khadem, Henry Thompson?
Choose the person with whom you would most like to work, write an account of his/her life, and say why you chose him/her rather than any of the others.
Replies to 2 of your classmates' threads - If possible, choose Threads which deal with different people.
What are your thoughts about the people chosen, and their influence on the dialog between Science and Religion?

Discussion Board 8, Module 8
Thread - Whom would you most like to have as a mentor :
Ursula Goodenough, Thomas Odhiambo (if he were still alive), Satoto?
Choose the person with whom you would most like to work, write an account of his/her life, and say why you chose him/her rather than any of the others.
Replies to 2 of your classmates' threads : - If possible, choose Threads which deal with different people.
What are your thoughts about the people chosen, and their influence on the dialog between Science and Religion?

Discussion Board 9, Module 9
Thread - What insights has this week's reading given you into the dialog between Science and Religion? Discuss at least one leading idea which came to you as you read these chapters
Replies to 2 of your classmates' threads - What are your thoughts about the insights and ideas of your classmates?

Discussion Board 10, Module 10
Thread : Whom would you most like to have been, or to have had as a mentor : Immanuel Kant, Robert Jastrow, Arnio Penzias, Gregor Mendel, Archibald Garrod, Francis Crick, Rosalind Franklin, ?
Choose whom you would most like to have been, or to have had as a mentor, write an account of his/her life, and say why you chose him/her rather than any of the others.
Replies to 2 of your classmates' threads : - If possible, choose Threads which deal with different people.
What are your thoughts about the people chosen, and their influence on the dialog between Science and Religion?

Discussion Board 11, Module 11
Thread :
Whom would you most like to have been, or to have had as a mentor : Buzz Aldrin, Augustine of Hippo, Alister McGrath, Stephen J. Gould, Asa Gray, Charles D. Walcott, Theodosius Dobzhansky, Benjamin Warfield?
Choose whom you would most like to have been, or to have had as a mentor, write an account of his life, and say why you chose him rather than any of the others.
Replies to 2 of your classmates' threads : - If possible, choose Threads which deal with different people.
What are your thoughts about the people chosen, and their influence on the dialog between Science and Religion?

Discussion Board 12, Module 12
Thread : What insights has Dr. Collins' book given you into the dialog between Science and Religion? Discuss at least one leading idea which came to you as you read this book
Replies to 2 of your classmates' threads : - What are your thoughts about the insights and ideas of your classmates?

Discussion Board 13, Module 13
Thread : What insights and ideas has this week's reading given you into the ethical and moral questions raised by science and medicine today, and how we should address them? Discuss at least one leading idea which came to you as you read the appendix
Replies to 2 of your classmates' threads - What are your thoughts about the insights and ideas of your classmates?

Discussion Board 14, Module 14
Thread : Whom would you most like to have been, or to have had as a mentor :
Robert Pollack, Donna Auguste, Isadore Rabi, John Templeton?
Choose whom you would most like to have been, or to have had as a mentor, write an account of his/her life, and say why you chose him/her rather than any of the others.
Replies to 2 of your classmates' threads - If possible, choose Threads which deal with different people.
What are your thoughts about the people chosen, and their influence on the dialog between Science and Religion?

Discussion Board 15, Module 15
Thread : Whom would you most like to have been, or to have had as a mentor :
Jane Goodall, Hendrik Barendregt, Maria Montessori, Philip Clayton??
Choose whom you would most like to have been, or to have had as a mentor, write an account of his/her life, and say why you chose him/her rather than any of the others.
Replies to 2 of your classmates' threads - If possible, choose Threads which deal with different people.
What are your thoughts about the people chosen, and their influence on the dialog between Science and Religion?

Final Message :
Say goodbye to your classmates, with thanks for ideas and help if appropriate.
If you plan to graduate at the end of this semester, what are your plans for the future?
If you are continuing towards your degree, which courses are you enrolled in for next semester?
You do not need to reply to any of the messages, but you may do so if you wish.

Discussion Boards 1-15 have the potential of earning 6 points each : 4 for the initial thread, and 1 each for two of your replies to other threads.

Thread - 4 points
Criteria	Proficient	Developing	Below Expectations
Relevance and Accuracy 0 - 2 points	Addresses all the points asked. Accurate, balanced presentation. 2 points	Misses part of what was asked, or Some inaccuracies. 1 point	Posts off-topic. 0 points
Style, Length, Timeliness 0 - 2 points	Posted on time. Meets the length requirement of 300-500 words. Correct grammar and spelling throughout. Stylistically elegant. Sentences are complete. Word choice is accurate and appropriate. Tone is appropriate - no use of slang or colloquialisms. Work is free of plagiarism or excessive copy-and-paste material. 2 points	Does not meet the length requirement of 300-500 words, or Posted up to 24 hours late Sentences are complete. Word choice is accurate. Tone is appropriate. Some minor grammatical or spelling mistakes. Work is free of plagiarism or excessive copy-and-paste material. 1 point	Work needs help from the Writing Lab. Plagiarism or excessive copy-and-paste material. Posted more than 24 hours late. After the Drop-Add period, threads posted more than 24 hours late receive a total score of 0 - zero. 0 points

Replies to two threads - 1 point each
Criteria	Proficient	Developing	Below Expectations
Relevance 0.5 point	Addresses the substance of the thread. Contains at least two positive comments and one point for reflection on the thread 0.5 point	Addresses only part of the thread. Does not contain at least two positive comments and one point for reflection on the thread. 0.25 point	Does not address the thread. 0 points
Style, Timeliness, and Length 0.5 point	Correct grammar and spelling throughout. Sentences are complete. Tone is appropriate. Replied on time. Meets the length requirement of 100-200 words. Work is free of plagiarism or excessive copy-and-paste material. 0.5 point	Work is free of plagiarism or excessive copy-and-paste material. Some minor grammatical or spelling mistakes, or Replied up to 24 hours late, or Does not meet the length requirement of 100-200 words 0.25 point	Work needs help from the Writing Lab, or Replied more than 24 hours late, or Plagiarism or excessive copy-and-paste material. 0 points

RELG 340 - Science and Religion

Discussion Board